Running the firm on systems · Guide 10 of 10

Which jobs should we automate first, and which should we leave alone?

Forty ideas for using AI and budget for three. A way to rank work by volume, rules and risk, what to leave with people, and examples by department.

On this page · 9 sections
  1. What makes a task a good one to automate first?
  2. Should we think in jobs or in tasks?
  3. How do we score the list?
  4. Which tasks come first, department by department?
  5. What should we leave alone?
  6. How much checking does automated work need?
  7. What to do this month
  8. Questions founders ask
  9. Sources

Someone on your team has a list. It has forty ideas for using AI on it, from writing proposals to answering the phone, and every one sounds plausible. You can afford to do two or three properly this year. The question is which.

Picking badly is a common way for these projects to fail. A study by MIT's NANDA initiative, reported by Fortune in August 2025, found that more than half of generative AI budgets went on sales and marketing tools, while the biggest returns came from back-office automation. Most pilots in the study stalled with little or no measurable effect on profit.

This guide gives you a way to rank work by three things: how much of it there is, how closely it follows rules, and what happens when it goes wrong. It also says what to leave with people, with examples by department.

What makes a task a good one to automate first?

Three things: there is a lot of it, it follows rules you could write down, and a mistake is cheap to catch and fix. A task that passes all three is a safe first project. A task that fails any one needs more care, or should wait.

Test Question to ask Good sign Warning sign
Volume How many times a week does this happen, and how many hours does it take in total? Daily or weekly, across several people A few times a year
Rules Could you write the steps on one page so that a new starter could follow them? Same inputs, same steps, same output "It depends" at every step
Risk If it goes wrong, who sees it, what does it cost, and can it be undone? Internal, visible, easy to correct Reaches a customer, moves money, or affects someone's job or credit

Volume tells you whether the saving is worth the effort. Rules tell you whether it can be built at all. Risk tells you how much checking it needs, and whether a person must approve the result.

Should we think in jobs or in tasks?

Tasks. Very few jobs are routine from end to end, and very few have no routine in them.

Take a credit controller. The National Careers Service lists the day-to-day work as checking credit ratings and setting up accounts, speaking with customers to arrange repayments, starting legal proceedings when debts are not paid, processing payments and keeping records up to date, and producing credit reports for management. Record keeping and reports follow rules. Reminders follow a schedule. The phone call with a customer in difficulty, and the decision to go to court, do not.

The research points the same way. The International Labour Organization found in May 2025 that one in four workers is in an occupation with some exposure to generative AI, with clerical occupations the most exposed, and concluded that "transformation of jobs is the most likely impact". A study of 5,179 customer support agents by Erik Brynjolfsson and colleagues found that an AI assistant raised the number of issues resolved per hour by 14% on average and by 34% for novice and low-skilled workers, with minimal effect on experienced ones. The tool took over the routine part of the job and helped newer people most.

So list tasks. You will end up changing what a role contains, not deleting the role.

How do we score the list?

Give every task a score from 1 to 3 on each test, then sort. It takes a team lead about an hour for their own area.

Step 1: List tasks, not roles

Ask each team lead for the tasks their people repeat. "Finance" is not a task. "Send the second reminder for an overdue invoice" is.

Step 2: Score volume

Score 3 for work that happens daily and adds up to several hours a week, 2 for weekly work, 1 for anything monthly or rarer. Write the hours a week next to it.

Step 3: Score rules

Score 3 if the steps fit on a page and the same input always leads to the same output. Score 2 if most cases follow the rules and a few need a person. Score 1 if every case is different.

Step 4: Score risk

Score 3 for low risk: the output stays inside the firm and can be corrected. Score 2 if it reaches a customer or moves money but a person can check it first. Score 1 if a mistake could harm a client, breach a regulation, or decide something important about an individual.

Step 5: Sort into four groups

Group Profile What to do Examples
Automate High volume, clear rules, low risk Let the system do it and check a sample Updating customer records, writing up call notes as actions, the weekly numbers
Automate with approval High volume, clear rules, reaches a customer or moves money The system prepares it, a person approves it Invoices, payment reminders, first sales emails, standard contracts
Assist Repeated, but each case needs judgement AI drafts or researches, a person does the work Proposals, client reports, hard customer cases with a summary attached
Leave alone Low volume, or high stakes People do it Complaints, pricing, advice, hiring choices

Step 6: Choose two or three and write the approval rule

Take the highest scores from the first two groups. For each, write down who approves the output, where the record of each action is kept, and how you will know it is working. What automating a department costs compared with hiring covers the money side, and our own prices are on what it costs.

Which tasks come first, department by department?

In most firms the first candidates are in administration, sales support and finance admin. The table below uses the split we publish on our Business Operating System page.

Department Good first tasks Leave with people
Marketing Turning customer questions and sales calls into draft posts, emails and pages; scheduling; the monthly report Approving the message and the tone
Sales Building and scoring prospect lists, researching each firm, drafting first emails and follow-ups, updating records Approving what is sent, taking the meeting
Customer service Answering common questions from your own help pages, passing hard cases on with a summary Complaints and judgement calls
Finance Raising the invoice when a deal is signed, chasing late payers on a schedule, the weekly cash report Sign-off of the books by your accountant
Contracts Filling standard contracts from templates, tracking renewal dates, flagging unusual clauses Legal advice from your solicitor
Hiring Writing job ads, booking interviews, onboarding checklists Choosing who to hire
Reporting Pulling numbers from every tool into one weekly page Deciding what to do about it

Outside evidence supports starting here. The government's AI adoption survey of 3,503 UK businesses found that AI was most commonly embedded in administration (81% of those using or planning to use it), marketing (71%) and IT (66%). McKinsey's 2023 study estimated that about 75% of the value of generative AI falls in four areas: customer operations, marketing and sales, software engineering and research and development. Anthropic's Economic Index for March 2026, which tracks how its Claude models are used, reports that customer service tasks such as payment and billing support are common in the work businesses run through its API, and that sales and outreach automation at least doubled its share.

Two cautions on sales and marketing. Outbound email has legal rules of its own, covered in whether cold emailing other businesses is legal in the UK. And content written by AI with nobody's expertise behind it does little for you, as we explain in whether ChatGPT and Google will quote content written with AI.

What should we leave alone?

Leave anything where the judgement is the job, where a mistake is expensive, or where the law expects a person. Five kinds of work belong here.

Complaints and difficult conversations. Klarna said its AI assistant could do the work of 700 customer service agents. In 2025 its chief executive told Bloomberg that cost had been "a too predominant evaluation factor" and that "what you end up having is lower quality", and the company began hiring human agents again, as CX Today reported.

Promises to customers. In February 2024 a Canadian tribunal found Air Canada liable for negligent misrepresentation after its website chatbot gave a customer wrong information about bereavement fares. The tribunal held that the airline was responsible for all the information on its website, whether it came from a static page or a chatbot, according to the American Bar Association's account. It is a Canadian case, but the lesson travels: your system speaks for you.

Advice and regulated work. The Solicitors Regulation Authority tells law firms in its report on AI that "you will remain responsible and accountable for the outputs from AI you are using", and adds: "Do not trust an AI system to judge its own accuracy." Other regulated professions should assume the same.

Significant decisions about individuals. Under the Information Commissioner's Office's draft guidance, updated in March 2026, a person affected by a significant decision made solely by automated means must be told about it, be able to put their side, get a human to review it and challenge it. The reviewer needs the authority to change the outcome. The ICO's own example is a loan decision. If software alone ever rejects a job applicant or refuses a customer credit, expect the same rules to apply.

Work AI is not good at. In an experiment with 758 BCG consultants, researchers from Harvard and elsewhere found that on tasks within AI's abilities the consultants using it completed 12.2% more tasks, 25.1% more quickly, at more than 40% higher quality. On a task chosen to be outside those abilities, consultants using AI were 19 percentage points less likely to produce a correct answer. It is not always obvious in advance which kind a task is, so test before you trust.

Leave low-volume work alone too, and any process that changes every month. What stays with people when AI does the routine work goes further into this side.

How much checking does automated work need?

More than you expect at the start, and less as the record builds. Begin with a person approving everything, then relax it only for internal, low-risk work.

Most UK firms already work this way. In the government survey, 81% of businesses said they apply some level of human input or oversight to AI outputs, and 56% of businesses that had adopted AI reported concerns about bias and accuracy.

Our rule is simple. Anything that reaches a customer or moves money is approved by a person, and every action is logged so you can see what the system did and why. We hold ourselves to it: our own sales desk drafts every first email and follow-up, and a founder approves every message. How we run Fortitude shows the split in each area.

Approval has to be real. A person who clicks "approve" on two hundred items without reading them is not a check. Keep batches small enough to read, and give the approver the authority to say no.

What to do this month

  1. Ask each team lead for the ten tasks their people repeat most often.
  2. Score every task from 1 to 3 on volume, rules and risk.
  3. Sort the list into the four groups: automate, automate with approval, assist, leave alone.
  4. Pick the two or three highest scorers and write down the steps for each on one page.
  5. Decide who will approve the output of each, and where the log will be kept.
  6. Write down the tasks you have decided to leave with people, and tell the team.

If you would like a second opinion on your list, book a conversation: 30 minutes with a founder, at no charge, and you leave with three areas a system could take on, in writing.

Frequently asked questions

Should we start with customer-facing work or the back office?

The back office, in most firms. The MIT study reported by Fortune found the biggest returns in back-office automation, and mistakes there are seen by you before they are seen by a customer. Customer-facing work can follow once the approval habit is in place.

Can AI answer our customers directly?

For common questions with settled answers, drawn from your own help pages, yes. Hard cases, complaints and anything involving a promise or a refund should go to a person with a summary. Remember the Air Canada ruling: the firm answers for what its chatbot says.

What if the process is a mess?

Fix it first. A task that scores 1 on rules cannot be automated well, because nobody can say what the right output is. Write the steps down, run them by hand for a month, then score the task again.

Is it worth automating a task that takes ten minutes?

It depends how often it happens. Ten minutes, thirty times a day, across a team is 25 hours a week. Ten minutes once a month is not worth building anything for.

Will automating tasks cost people their jobs?

The International Labour Organization's view is that jobs are more likely to change than to disappear, because most roles include tasks that need a person. In practice the routine part of a role shrinks, and the firm decides what that time is now for. Make that decision before you build, and tell the people affected.

Sources

David Adams
Written by

David Adams

Co-founder and CEO, Fortitude Media · AI and automation

David spent thirteen years in SaaS, from retention calls to COO and then CRO of a £30 million partner-led business. He runs Fortitude, builds the tools behind it and runs Pipeline That Fills.

  • Websites
  • Getting named by AI
  • The business case
  • Meetings and pipeline
More from David

fortitudemedia.ai/insights/which-jobs-to-automate-first · Book a conversation at fortitudemedia.ai/growth-review

Ready to find out where you stand?

Book a conversation. 30 minutes with a founder, no charge.

Book a conversation ↗

How we do this for clients: Business Operating System · How we run our own firm · Pricing

10% of everything we invoice goes to founders in crisis, through the Fortitude Foundation. It costs you nothing extra.

How the 10% works

Built for the businessyou're becoming.

Book a conversation30 minutes with a founder. No charge. You leave with it in writing.
Talk to FortitudeAI drafts the answers. A founder reads every conversation.